Monday, January 14, 2008

Crime and Punishment

Is Raskolnikov mentally ill?

Many would say yes because he murdered two innocent women for reasons many us do not understand and throughout the novel Raskolnikov's multiple personalities are revealed therefore making him appear insane. Rodya does not see himself as crazy and believes his reasoning behinde his actions is just. If you believe something is right in your mind, then how can you be wrong, who determines right from wrong?
-In order for one to be mentally ill do they have to admit to themselves that they are ill?
-If Rodya is insane why does he feel guilty about the murders?
-When he confesses to the murders is he admiting to himself that he is wrong, and therefore crazy?

Raskolnikov's theory that some men are on a higher pedestal, also known as the superman theory, gives an explanation to his actions, but does he truly believe he is one of these special individuals? If these few individuals think differently than the rest of the population, they wouldn't necessarily be crazy but just able to come to a different conclusion and in their minds they are correct. Are these "special" human beings the normal one's and the rest of the population wrong in their intrepratations and conclusions of situations?

Thursday, November 1, 2007

Ghosts

In our smaller group on Aug. 31st we touched on many different topics from Ghosts, but some of the most prominent ideas are:
-Manders and Mrs. Alving are more than just friends
-Engstrand doesn't give into temptation like Manders, but he is selfish
-Ghosts focuses on peoples reputations in a community and how important they are/morals are based on perspective
-We believe that the different translations of the play change some of the interpretations-"The one that I inherited, the illness-(Points to his forehead and speaks very softly.)-that's seated here."(3 pgs from the end.) But, some of the other books say "that lies here". Does this have a different interpretations?-Mrs. Alving seems to be over-dramatic, but is she just being rational?

How this relates to my Big Question:
At the end of the play when Osvald gets sick because of the disease he inherited from his father, he not only appears to be sick physically, but mentally as well. But, is he mentally sick becasue of the disease or was it becasue he discovered his fathers true-self years after his death. His father's actions affected him and the person he becomes because the disease controls his life now. But, the false image of his father that was portrayed to Osvald at a young age affects the stability of his mind because he second guesses his childhood, and if it was all a lie.